From: D.J. Keenan
To: d.troy@qub.ac.uk
Cc: info.compliance@qub.ac.uk
Sent: 21 September 2010 15:40
Subject: Your ref: FOI/10/66
Dear Ms. Troy,
I refer to your letter of June 4th, pertaining to FOI/10/66.
The table at
contains data about trees that were living at the time of
sampling. I have several questions regarding the table. As
an example, the site of Shane's is said to have a tree, Q1651, that was living
at the time of sampling--yet there is no ring-width data for tree
Q1651 available via
nor is any listed in the ITRDB; where can the ring-width
data be found? A list of issues is appended.
Sincerely,
Douglas Keenan
#Site name /No. of samples / Date / QUB numbers
Birr 4 2009 Q11204---Q11207 Q11204 MISSING
Kilmahog 10 2004
Q10621---30 Q10628 MISSING
Ardress 3 2003 Q10560---2
MISSING
Hamilton 2 2003 Q10558---9 MISSING
Armagh 1 2003
Q10460 MISSING
Ardress 11 2002 Q10392---Q10402
MISSING
Argory 3 2002 Q10412---4 MISSING
Woods 1 2002
Q10437 MISSING
Deans 15 2002
Q10221---5,Q10266---75 Named DEAN'S HILL? Q10266-20269 AND
Q10271-Q10275 MISSING
Ardress 9 2002 Q10403---Q10411 MISSING
Argory
22 2002 Q10415---Q10436 MISSING
Observatory 35 2001
Q10085---91,97---99,Q10147---52,Q10162---64,Q10171---86
Q10086-91, Q10097-99, Q10147-52, Q10162-64, Q10180-86 MISSING.
Mall 7
2001 Q10156---9,Q10080,82 Q10157-9 MISSING.
Deans 6 2001
Q10165---Q10170 MISSING
Massacre 4 2000 Q9964---67
MISSING
Mount_Noir 6 2000 Q9968---73 MISSING
Risol 8 2000
Q9952---9 MISSING
Risoux 4 2000 Q9960---3
MISSING
Hollymount 12 1999 Q9838---45,Q9903---9906
MISSING
Tollymore 33 1998 Q9611---14,Q9728,Q9700---27
Q9728 MISSING
Rostrevor 6 1996 Q9231---Q9238
Are 9235 and 9236 really Rostrevor?
Guadapin 5 1996
Q9195---99 MISSING
Real 1 1996 Q9200
MISSING
Mountain_Road 3 1995 Q9135---7 MISSING
Killarney 3
1995 Q9104---6 MISSING
Pontoon 8 1995
Q8951---57 Q8955 MISSING
Rostrevor 25 1995
Q9144---68 Q9144, Q9145 MISSING
Shane’s 16 1992
Q8758N---61w MISSING
Gram 33 1985
Q5549---60,Q5598---Q6508 MISSING
Nodebo 16 1985
Q5596,Q5612---26 MISSING
Vallo 8 1985
Q5588---5595 MISSING
Draved 12 1985 Q5523---34
MISSING
Jaegerpris 27 1985 Q5561---5587 MISSING
Kristiansaede
9 1985 Q5541---5611 MISSING
Linet 6 1985 Q5517---22
MISSING
Peterstrup 8 1985 Q5535---40,Q5609---10
MISSING
Derramore 5 1984 Q5232,Q5242---5 MISSING
Barnett 2
1984 Q5240---1 MISSING
Dixon’s 4 1984 Q5247---51
MISSING. Is 5248 is Black pigs dyke?
NFL 1 1984 Q5233
MISSING
Ormeau 3 1984 Q5231,Q5234---5 MISSING
Holywood 2 1984
Q5237---8 MISSING
Saintfield 1 1984 Q5239
MISSING
Turku 45 1984 Q5423---Q5467 MISSING
26,29,30,31,33,35,37,39,42,44,45,46
Azay 7 1984 Q5315---21
5315 and 5321 MISSING. Named AZAY-LE-RIDEAU. Is this really all
recent?
Sallas 2 1984 Q5323---4 MISSING
Theo 1 1984
Q5322 MISSING
Cadzow 44 1984 Q5253---Q5391
MISSING
Shane’s 23 1983 Q5129---Q5229 Are there sequences
intermixed from other sites?
Cadzow 15 1983 Q5091---Q5104
MISSING
Tollymore 55 1982 Q4757---85,Q4797---Q4825
MISSING
Barnett 7 1981 Q4750---6 MISSING
Tollymore 21 1981
Q4635---38 MISSING
Azay 8 1980 Q4053---Q4060 Is this really
all recent?
Blere 8 1980 Q3993---Q4000 Q4000 is MISSING
Gavre
21 1980 Q4203---Q4223 MISSING
Chambord 20 1979
Q3775---Q3794 MISSING
Chinon 20 1979 Q3838---Q3857
MISSING
Fontainebleau 27 1979 Q3608---Q3634 MISSING
Halatte 26
1979 Q3875---Q3900 MISSING
Guibes 18 1979
Q3757---Q3774 MISSING
New Forest 10 1979
Q3733---Q3742 MISSING
Blickling 18 1979
Q3588---Q3605 3605 IS MISSING
Doon_Lough 18
1978 Q3385---Q3402 3400-3402 MISSING. Named Loch
Doon?
Castle_Archdale 1 1978 Q3270 MISSING
Coral_Glen 6 1978
Q3264---Q3269 MISSING
Killarney 19 1978 Q3367---Q3971
3971 MISSING
Perth 6 1978 Q3271---Q3276
3271 MISSING
Cadzow 11 1977 Q2818---Q2825, Q2651---2
MISSING
Dee 30 1977 Q3145---Q3165 3162-3165 MISSING.
Named River Dee?
Downpatrick 2 1977 Q2975, Q2971
MISSING
Lockwood 29 1976 Q2544---Q2565. MISSING
48,49,51,52,54,56,60,61,63,65
Raehills 11 1976 Q2533---Q2543
2543 MISSING
Lomond 1 1976 Q2548 MISSING
Powerscourt 4
1976 Q2601---Q2604 MISSING
Pilling 1 1975 Q2345
MISSING
Wenland 2 1975 Q2343---Q2344 MISSING
Otmoor 2 1975
Q2341---2 MISSING
Castle_rock 22 1975
Q2319---Q2340 MISSING
Shane’s 26 1974
Q1626---Q1651 1646-51 MISSING
Caledon 20 1974
Q1689---Q1709 Only Q1689A published. Named
CDP?
Deerpark 2 1974 Q2095---6 Only Q2095
published. Named ANTRIM?
Castlewellan 2 1974 Q1971---2
MISSING
Tollymore 1 1974 Q2185 MISSING
Lockwood 11
1974 Q1973---Q1983 1975,77,79,80,82,83
MISSING
Pomeroy 16 1974 Q1549---Q1564 1549, 50,51,58-64
MISSING
Barnett 18 1974 Q1565---Q1688 Is 1565-77
MOTORWAY?
Shane’s 7 1973 Q1165---Q1171
1168,70,71 MISSING
Flosses 10 1973 Q1150---9
Only 1156 in place?
Antrim 2 1970 Q457---8 458
MISSING
Barnett 11 1970 Q459---Q469 460,61,63-67
MISSING.
Kiltierney 2 2009 Q1128---9 Named KDP? Corresponds to
samples marked Saintfield House?
Donaghadee 1 2004 Q10650 Named
DPS?
Lomond 7 2002 Q10320---26 Named LOCH LOMOND?
Foaty 3 2002
Q10209---11 Named FOATY ISLAND?
Hamilton 2 2002 Q1038---9 -
Named SPRINGHILL HOUSE?
Drains 1 2000 Q10036 Named Drains
Bay?
Oakley 10 1978 Q3403---Q3412 Named Oxford?
Otmoor 5 1978
Q3414---Q3418 Named Oxford?
Studley 1 1978
Q3413 Named Oxford?
Grave 21 1984 Q5359---79
Named Point de Grave?
Muckross 1 1996 Q9388 Named Muckross
House?
Lebanon 14 1986 Q6059---72 Named WASSER CHOUF and
BCHARRE?
Barnett 2 2006 Q10808---9 Is Q10809 named
Templeogue ?
Nodebo Q5624-5626 are marked Ballinderry?